So, you’re thinking about getting a dog? That’s awesome. Prepare to never use the bathroom alone again and to find hair in places hair has no business being. I’ve been looking at these charts ranking "best dogs for first-time owners," and honestly, some of it is spot-on, while some of it feels like it was written by someone who has never actually lived with a furry chaotic roommate.
Choosing a dog isn't just about picking the cutest face (though, let’s be real, that’s 90% of the battle). It’s about matching your level of "chill" with theirs. If you’re a couch potato and you get a dog that needs to run ten miles a day, you’re both going to end up crying.
The "Good Boys" and the Overachievers
According to the "Recommended" list, Pomeranians and Schnauzers are the gold standard. I get it. They’re small, they don’t eat you out of house and home, and they generally think you’re the center of the universe. The chart also lists the Border Collie as a top-tier recommendation, and this is where I have to pause and look you in the eye.
Border Collies are geniuses. They aren't just "smart"; they are "I might figure out your ATM PIN" smart. If you don't give them a job, they will invent one, and usually, that job involves herding your houseguests into the kitchen or systematically deconstructing your sofa to see how it works. On the other hand, the "Average" list mentions Labradors and Golden Retrievers. These are the classic "starter dogs" for a reason. They’re basically just happy, shedding rugs that occasionally want a snack. Just watch out for that "large appetite"—a Lab will look at a discarded sock and see a five-course meal.
And then there's the Corgi. The chart says they are "easy-to-train." Sure, if they feel like it. Corgis have a lot of opinions for creatures with two-inch legs. They’re adorable, but they’ve got a "managerial" vibe that can be a bit much for a first-timer who isn't ready to be bossed around by a loaf of bread.
The "Proceed with Caution" Crew
Now, let’s talk about the "Not Recommended" list. It includes Huskies, Malamutes, and Samoyeds. The chart calls them "silly" breeds, which is a very polite way of saying "total drama queens." If you want a dog that will literally argue with you when you tell it to sit, get a Husky. They don’t bark; they scream. It’s like living with a furry opera singer who is constantly offended by the weather.
The French Bulldog is also on the "no" list for beginners, mostly because of the snoring and... well, the flatulence. I actually have a buddy, Mark, who didn't listen to this advice. He’s a total first-timer, lives in a tiny apartment, and fell in love with a Frenchie named Gus.
Mark thought, "How hard can it be? He’s small!" Two weeks in, Mark calls me at 2:00 AM. He sounds traumatized. Apparently, Gus had a "gastric event" so potent it set off the carbon monoxide detector. Okay, maybe not literally, but Mark had to sleep on the balcony for an hour to clear his lungs. Between the snoring that sounds like a chainsaw and the stubbornness—Gus refuses to walk if it’s slightly misty outside—Mark learned the hard way that "low exercise" doesn't mean "low maintenance."
My Takeaway for You
If I were in your shoes, I’d look closely at that Shiba Inu on the "Average" list. They’re loyal, but they’re basically cats in dog suits. They don't need your constant validation, which is great if you actually have a life. But if you want a shadow that lives for your every word, stick to the Golden Retriever. Just buy a really good vacuum first.
At the end of the day, these charts are just guides. Every dog is an individual. You might find a Husky who just wants to nap, or a Pomeranian who thinks he’s a Navy SEAL. Just be honest with yourself: Are you ready for a genius who outsmarts you, or do you just want a "silly" fluffball who farts in his sleep?
